Eat Your Feelings

Ingredients

Dark Chocolate Chip
Cocoa
Butter
Free Range Eggs
White Chocolate

Dark Chocolate Chips, Heavy Cream, Flour, Butter, Milk, Oats, Cocoa Powder, Brown Sugar, Vanilla, Sugar, Pecans, Free Range Eggs, Espresso, Marshmallows, Baking Soda, Lemon Juice, Salt

Baking & Serving Tips

Make sure to get the most enjoyable and best experience out of our pies by following the baking instructions and serving tips below. These instructions are specific to Eat Your Feelings. If you would like instructions for a different pie, please check that page.

Cream Pies

The Eat Your Feelings should be refrigerated at all times. For best results, the pie should be consumed within 3 days of purchase. Before serving, please remove from fridge and leave at room temperature for 30 minutes. Ideally you do not want your cream pie to sit at room temperature for longer than 1 hour.

Tips

While you can freeze a cream pie, it is not recommended. The whipped cream and the custard are both best consumed when fresh.
To cut a perfect slice, try warming your knife blade with hot water and cleaning it between cuts.
Never warm a cream pie, as the filling and whipped cream will not survive the heat.

2024-02-11 03:46:16 UTC

Jason Crowther said: Eat me feelings

🤤

2023-02-21 02:22:53 UTC

christina said: A unique pie

I found the pie a little-too sweet, but what was great was that it was so rich i had the 5 inch sized pie twice. It certainly is a guilty pleasure. Looking forward to trying a different valentine’s day pie next year!

It is definitely on the sweeter side. Glad you found the right pace ;) Thanks Christina

2022-03-05 03:21:26 UTC

Max Cowan said: Rich and chewy

Almost like a cookie pie, if that's your thing.

...and if cookies and pies aren't your thing, you might be on the wrong website ;P Thanks so much Max

2022-02-18 22:36:45 UTC

David Charron said: Eat You Feelings...as I did

This may be the new best pie...overwhelmingly well-received by everyone at the soirée.

Yes! Teamwork feelings eating! Thanks so much for the review David :)

2022-02-15 22:23:54 UTC

Kayla said: Can this be around all the time?

Absolutely delicious - please, please make this available all year round!!

Glad you liked it so much Kayla! Thanks for the review.

2022-01-30 18:22:06 UTC

Ruth de Jesus said: I wish this was available year round!

OK I know I know, this is a Valentine’s Day pie. Great name by the way. I just wish I could get it anytime because it’s that good. It reminds me of a cross between a chocolate oatmeal Rockyroad cookie and slice of white chocolate pecan pie. But somehow it’s not too sweet!?!? It’s just perfect.

Thanks so much Ruth! Cruel as it sounds, I am glad you want this limited pie so badly haha. Appreciate the review.

2020-02-11 18:14:46 UTC

Carl Densem said: Delicious!

Eat Your Feelings is decadent with layers of rich chocolate, crunchiness and a flaky crust.

Thanks for the review, Carl. We invite you to eat your feelings anytime ;)

Ordering Details

All pies ordered online are ready after 1:00pm on your selected date (chosen during checkout).

Using online shopping you can order pies in 9-inch, 5-inch, 3-inch (9-pack), hand pie (5-pack), or mini hand pies (12-pack).

To order this product online, select a size followed by selecting options (like the ‘Top’ or ‘Frozen’, if applicable) and then click on “Add to Cart”. As you go through the checkout process, you will be able to specify a date for pick up. At least 36 hours notice is required from the time you order (the system will not let you select a date in advance of this time). Your order will be freshly made and ready for you on the date specified!

Or come visit us at one of our locations for a freshly baked slice, infringement tart, or savoury hand pie to enjoy right there or packaged up to go. We also keep rotating stock on hand (first come, first served basis) of the 9-inch and 5-inch pies for those looking to take out.

Lastly, you can visit one of our Partner Retailers and pick up a pie there. Please call them in advance, as their stock is sure to be limited.

We take great pride in making each pie from scratch, by hand, and from locally sourced ingredients of the finest quality. Should you be unhappy with your pie, please return it to the shop you purchased it from and a credit will be applied upon the discretion of the Manager.

Please note:

Orders can neither be changed, nor cancelled, with less than 36 hours notice.
Orders not picked up by store closing time on the specified pickup date will be released for sale or donated to charity without a refund.
All of our products contain eggs, dairy, sugar and gluten unless otherwise noted. Our products are made in a facility that contains milk, nuts and gluten and, while we take great care to avoid it, cross contamination may occur in a food preparation area.